The 100 Best High Schools in America
what is the point in ranking “america’s best high schools?” i don’t like this trend towards ranking everything- undergrad, grad programs, med schools, law schools, etc etc. but now they’re ranking high schools?! (i know washingtonpost had the rankings last year, but it seemed to just be local… this year, it seems newsweek has picked up their ranking system and made it the front of their latest issue) it seems pointless to rank high schools nationally. i understand how most parents would want to know the reputation of the neighborhood schools before purchasing a house, but national rankings? what’s the point? are people going to specifically move to an area to go to the #1 school if it’s in an area like say… nebraska? i think the location of parents’ jobs would still determine where the family would end up. so why bother comparing all the high school’s in the nation?
i actually think the judging criteria for ranking the schools (taking the number of AP or IB tests taken by all students at a school in divided by the number of graduating seniors) could lead to crappier education. i believe my high school (ranked #17 on the list) has taken this AP exam thing a bit too far. (of course, i graduated 5 years ago… so perhaps they’ve improved) my high school began to place a heavy emphasis on taking APs my senior year. i think teachers were encouraged to let any student take any APs they wanted to because really, who wants to discourage kids from learning if they’re willing to put the effort right? i guess it’d be ok to encourage kids to take the AP classes because they’ll theoretically learn more sitting in the class. but the judging criteria for the schools is based on the number of students taking the actual exams. i can easily see a school encouraging students to take the AP exams in an effort to boost their ranking. in a few of my classes, i felt pressured into taking the AP test (in fact, i vaguely remember in one of them the teacher said anyone who didn’t would have to do an extra project/test or something to make up).
well… being the great senior slacker that i was, i was not ready for ANY of my AP tests. but being the idiot that i was, i still signed up for 4 out of 5 of them (more on why i dropped one later). this resulted in me sleeping completely through the multiple choice section of Euro History (hey, if u’re gonna fail… why waste time? i was saving up my brain for the essay portion), breezing through the calc BC test with answers like “woohoo!” (yes… for math problems) and muddling my way through the other 2. what was the point?
i’m not trying to blame my teachers for my bad performance on the AP exams, that was entirely my fault. and they did translate into a few (heavy emphasis on few) credits when i went to college, so not all was lost. in the end, the responsibility for determining whether i was prepared for the tests was entirely on me (and in hindsight, i of course shouldn’t have bothered to sign up for these exams!). but i was always encouraged to sign up for all the APs… even in classes that i was taking pass/fail (AND nearly failing) i think it would’ve been a touchy subject had one of my teacher’s approached me about not taking the AP exam… but i think i also would’ve appreciated it since they would’ve been trying to save me money, or giving me a kick in the butt to study harder. they were my teachers and the “experts” in preparing for these exams and when they gave blanket statements telling us we were all ready for the AP exams and encouraging us to sign up for them, you tend to listen to them (and hope that a bit of last minute cramming will catch u up for a year’s worth of slacking off
)
finally… the reason why i ended up signing up for 4, and not all 5 of my APs senior year. my last AP class was AP english. This is what my class did throughout the semester- perform skits of scenes from hamlet, write poems about classmates (samples from the poems- “vicky, vicky, she’s so icky,”
“this is crystal, her name only rhymes with pistol”…), and draw pictures of the characters from the canterbury tales. does that seem like preparation for the APs or middle school english class? i think half my class didn’t bother to take the AP. they need to have better teachers!
i don’t think counting the number of AP exams is a good way to rank high schools. you could end up having a bunch of idiots, such as myself, signing up to take AP tests they are not ready for (whether that is because the student slacked off… or because the teacher didn’t prepare them well enough).
actually, i don’t think it’s a good thing to be ranking high schools to begin with!